| (Seed) Team | Week 1 April 28th | Week 2 May 5th | Week 3 May 12th | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (1) The Basement Sports Bar Akron, OH | (1) The Basement Sports Bar 57931 | (1) The Basement Sports Bar 59822 | (1) The Basement Sports Bar 58296 | (2) Teaser's |
| (2) Teaser's Chicago, IL | (8) Arch II Bar and Grill 42479 | |||
| (3) Time Out West Hanover Park, IL | (4) Moose McGuires 34098 | (5) Danny K's 57700 | ||
| (4) Moose McGuires Ottawa, ON | (5) Danny K's 48366 | |||
| (5) Danny K's Orange, CA | (3) Time Out West 46951 | (3) Time Out West 46188 | (2) Teaser's 58509 | |
| (6) Hanko's Sports Bar & Grill Lake Oswego, OR | (6) Hanko's Sports Bar & Grill 46318 | |||
| (7) Lost In Taste Christiansburg, VA | (2) Teaser's 50724 | (2) Teaser's 48142 | ||
| (8) Arch II Bar and Grill Rocky Hill, CT | (7) Lost In Taste 34785 |